validate-acceptance-checklist

Metadata

Status	done
Assigned	`agent-703`
Agent identity	`f51439356729d112a6c404803d88015d5b44832c6c584c62b96732b63c2b0c7e`
Created	2026-05-05T05:14:43.157491778+00:00
Started	2026-05-05T05:42:41.351754873+00:00
Completed	2026-05-05T05:50:29.204392448+00:00
Tags	`paper-prep,validation`, `eval-scheduled`
Eval score	0.82
└ blocking impact	0.90
└ completeness	0.90
└ constraint fidelity	0.85
└ coordination overhead	0.76
└ correctness	0.85
└ downstream usability	0.86
└ efficiency	0.76
└ intent fidelity	0.83
└ style adherence	0.72

Description

Final acceptance walk-through. Implement directly — do not decompose further.

Validation

Each of the 12 anchoring findings in SURVEY_10_11_12_limits_summary_lit.md §1.2 is supported by a Main / ED panel — table of which figure
27 novel contributions ledger: paper_prep/synthesis/NOVEL_CONTRIBUTIONS.tsv (5 columns: id / claim / metric / figure / TSV), one row per N1..N27 from SURVEY_10/11/12 §4.2
Limitations × findings cross-reference: paper_prep/synthesis/LIMITATIONS_X_FINDINGS.tsv per SURVEY_10/11/12 §6 T-5
Output: paper_prep/synthesis/ACCEPTANCE_CHECKLIST.md with all rows ✓ or with a flag pointing to a WORK_DECOMPOSITION.md ## Gaps entry

Inputs

paper_prep/synthesis/MANUSCRIPT_SKELETON.md, WORK_DECOMPOSITION.md
paper_prep/surveys/SURVEY_10_11_12_limits_summary_lit.md

## Description
Final acceptance walk-through. Implement directly — do not decompose further.

## Validation
- [ ] Each of the 12 anchoring findings in `SURVEY_10_11_12_limits_summary_lit.md §1.2` is supported by a Main / ED panel — table of which figure
- [ ] 27 novel contributions ledger: `paper_prep/synthesis/NOVEL_CONTRIBUTIONS.tsv` (5 columns: id / claim / metric / figure / TSV), one row per N1..N27 from `SURVEY_10/11/12 §4.2`
- [ ] Limitations × findings cross-reference: `paper_prep/synthesis/LIMITATIONS_X_FINDINGS.tsv` per `SURVEY_10/11/12 §6 T-5`
- [ ] Output: `paper_prep/synthesis/ACCEPTANCE_CHECKLIST.md` with all rows ✓ or with a flag pointing to a WORK_DECOMPOSITION.md ## Gaps entry

## Inputs
- `paper_prep/synthesis/MANUSCRIPT_SKELETON.md`, `WORK_DECOMPOSITION.md`
- `paper_prep/surveys/SURVEY_10_11_12_limits_summary_lit.md`

Depends on

Required by

Log

2026-05-05T05:31:15.059369883+00:00 Lightweight assignment: agent=Careful Programmer (f5143935), exec_mode=full, context_scope=task, reason=Careful Programmer excels at correctness-critical work requiring cross-file validation and structured output creation; high task count (83) and careful tradeoff match the final acceptance checklist requirements.
2026-05-05T05:42:41.351758400+00:00 Spawned by coordinator --executor claude --model opus
2026-05-05T05:42:54.616731239+00:00 Starting acceptance checklist validation. No prior WIP. Will inspect inputs first.
2026-05-05T05:44:16.780357671+00:00 Inputs reviewed: SURVEY_10/11/12 (12 findings, 27 N#, 18 limitations), MANUSCRIPT_SKELETON (4 main + 8 ED + 4 tables), WORK_DECOMPOSITION (figure tasks + gaps). Now generating 3 deliverables.
2026-05-05T05:49:53.418087375+00:00 Validated all 4 acceptance rows: A. 12/12 findings mapped to Main/ED panels (Section A table). B. NOVEL_CONTRIBUTIONS.tsv 27 rows × 5 cols (N1..N27 sequential). C. LIMITATIONS_X_FINDINGS.tsv 12 rows × 6 cols, all L1..L18 + preface accounted for. D. ACCEPTANCE_CHECKLIST.md with 7 documented gap-pointer flags into WORK_DECOMPOSITION.md gaps 11–18.
2026-05-05T05:50:24.685710737+00:00 Committed: d3ca075 — pushed to origin/wg/agent-703/validate-acceptance-checklist
2026-05-05T05:50:29.204398670+00:00 Task pending eval (agent reported done; awaiting `.evaluate-*` to score)
2026-05-05T05:58:14.706802688+00:00 PendingEval → Done (evaluator passed; downstream unblocks)