quality-pass-pi-3 — WorksGood live mirror

Metadata

Status	done
Assigned	`agent-893`
Agent identity	`603daf069cd2ae4a26357aa66e8c6124154b648711a0816ffd8b660ee3b23815`
Created	2026-07-26T16:43:17.694045078+00:00
Started	2026-07-26T16:43:42.734915390+00:00
Completed	2026-07-26T16:47:14.403925210+00:00
Tokens	635726 in / 6824 out

Description

Purpose

Quality-gate the watchdog completion-policy amendment. Silence must never be mistaken for completion or failure; five minutes may begin observation/probing but must not be a universal hard-interruption deadline for slow/cheap routes. Review/edit task metadata only.

Validation

Done proof requires current-epoch explicit terminal receipt plus candidate/finalization evidence, never elapsed time.
Agent-settled, process-exit, provider-in-flight, active progress, long tool, user wait, unknown silence, and no-terminal states have different actions.
Soft suspect and phase-specific hard-resume thresholds are separated.
Same-session stock completion prompt and finite budgets are safe/idempotent.
Initial policy is conservative/static while recording route metrics for later ratified adaptation.

## Purpose
Quality-gate the watchdog completion-policy amendment. Silence must never be mistaken for completion or failure; five minutes may begin observation/probing but must not be a universal hard-interruption deadline for slow/cheap routes. Review/edit task metadata only.

## Validation
- [ ] Done proof requires current-epoch explicit terminal receipt plus candidate/finalization evidence, never elapsed time.
- [ ] Agent-settled, process-exit, provider-in-flight, active progress, long tool, user wait, unknown silence, and no-terminal states have different actions.
- [ ] Soft suspect and phase-specific hard-resume thresholds are separated.
- [ ] Same-session stock completion prompt and finite budgets are safe/idempotent.
- [ ] Initial policy is conservative/static while recording route metrics for later ratified adaptation.

Depends on

done design-pi-stalled

Required by

done amend-pi-watchdog

Log

2026-07-26T16:43:17.673588792+00:00 Task paused
2026-07-26T16:43:42.074374575+00:00 Task published
2026-07-26T16:43:42.799679602+00:00 Spawned by coordinator --executor pi --model openai-codex:gpt-5.6-sol --isolation shared-nonwriting-policy
2026-07-26T16:43:52.576576869+00:00 Starting quality review of watchdog completion-policy metadata; will inspect the dependency design and amend only task metadata.
2026-07-26T16:44:51.161435913+00:00 Review finding: the source design still treats 300s + at most 180s grace as a near-universal fence for Active provider/generation phases. Completion/finalization and finite same-session recovery are strong, but the amendment must introduce an explicit evidence/action matrix and a distinct phase/route hard-resume threshold (low/free QoS >=900s), with unknown silence held rather than guessed.
2026-07-26T16:47:03.229103778+00:00 Validated task-specific criteria against amended amend-pi-watchdog metadata: Done requires a current-epoch wg_done receipt plus quiescence/manifest, candidate, validation/evaluation, and finalization evidence; ten observation states have distinct actions; 300s soft suspicion is separate from >=900s phase/route hard-resume eligibility; prompt/action replay and budgets are finite/idempotent; thresholds stay static while route metrics are recorded.
2026-07-26T16:47:03.280617284+00:00 Validated metadata-only scope: docs/design-pi-session-watchdog.md and repository files were not modified, so cargo/build and commit/push are not applicable.
2026-07-26T16:47:14.403925520+00:00 Task marked as done