peer-review-agency-csv — Workgraph live mirror

Metadata

Status	done
Assigned	`agent-2398`
Agent identity	`3184716484e6f0ea08bb13539daf07686ee79d440505f1fdf2de0357707034c3`
Model	`claude:opus`
Created	2026-05-04T17:43:27.456266253+00:00
Started	2026-05-04T19:14:03.979649912+00:00
Completed	2026-05-04T19:21:21.175846794+00:00
Tags	`agency,sync,peer-review,federation`, `eval-scheduled`
Eval score	0.88
└ blocking impact	0.92
└ completeness	0.90
└ coordination overhead	0.84
└ correctness	0.95
└ downstream usability	0.88
└ efficiency	0.86
└ intent fidelity	0.67
└ style adherence	0.90

Description

Cross-model peer review of impl-agency-csv-roundtrip. Verify byte-for-byte round-trip of agency starter CSV format.

What to check

All 12 columns parsed and emitted in the exact order agency uses
Domain column is comma-separated (NOT JSON array, per spec convention)
parent_ids column IS JSON array ["hash1","hash2"]
Test fixture is real agency starter data, not synthetic
Round-trip is byte-equal, not just semantically equal (preserves trailing newline, quote conventions)
Live smoke output confirms wg agency import --format agency-csv actually wrote primitives that show up in wg agency stats
File scope respected: no hash.rs / types.rs changes

Deliverable

wg log concur / concern verdict with file:line citations + a sample diff if any byte-level drift is found.

Validation

Read agency_import.rs and agency_push.rs diffs
Independently round-tripped the test fixture and confirmed byte-equality (or surfaced any drift)
Verified domain vs parent_ids serialization conventions match agency spec
Verdict posted via wg log

## Description
Cross-model peer review of `impl-agency-csv-roundtrip`. Verify byte-for-byte round-trip of agency starter CSV format.

## What to check
- All 12 columns parsed and emitted in the exact order agency uses
- Domain column is comma-separated (NOT JSON array, per spec convention)
- parent_ids column IS JSON array `["hash1","hash2"]`
- Test fixture is real agency starter data, not synthetic
- Round-trip is byte-equal, not just semantically equal (preserves trailing newline, quote conventions)
- Live smoke output confirms `wg agency import --format agency-csv` actually wrote primitives that show up in `wg agency stats`
- File scope respected: no hash.rs / types.rs changes

## Deliverable
`wg log` concur / concern verdict with file:line citations + a sample diff if any byte-level drift is found.

## Validation
- [ ] Read agency_import.rs and agency_push.rs diffs
- [ ] Independently round-tripped the test fixture and confirmed byte-equality (or surfaced any drift)
- [ ] Verified domain vs parent_ids serialization conventions match agency spec
- [ ] Verdict posted via `wg log`

Depends on

done .assign-peer-review-agency-csv

Required by

(none)

Log

2026-05-04T17:43:27.398724834+00:00 Task paused
2026-05-04T18:37:42.133666933+00:00 Task published
2026-05-04T18:38:13.714920168+00:00 Lightweight assignment: agent=Default Evaluator (31847164), exec_mode=light, context_scope=task, reason=This is a correctness-focused peer review task, so the balanced Evaluator is the best fit for checking round-trip behavior, fixture fidelity, and spec conformance without modifying files.
2026-05-04T19:14:03.979654541+00:00 Spawned by coordinator --executor claude --model opus
2026-05-04T19:14:14.351179410+00:00 Starting peer review — reading impl-agency-csv-roundtrip artifacts
2026-05-04T19:20:11.549546159+00:00 VERDICT: CONCUR. Findings: (1) 12-col header order pinned in src/commands/agency_push.rs:49-62; matches fixture line 1 byte-for-byte. (2) domain column = comma-separated text with CSV-Necessary quoting (agency_push.rs:253 join(','); fixture rows 3,6 quoted because of comma; rows 2,4,5,7 unquoted — single tag). NOT a JSON array. Spec convention upheld. (3) parent_ids IS a JSON array — agency_push.rs:273-279 uses serde_json::to_string; agency_import.rs:610-624 parses JSON first, falls back to comma-split. Raw string round-trips via metadata.parent_ids (import.rs:596-598 → push.rs:239-243), preserving '[]', '["scope-root"]', etc. byte-equal. (4) Fixture is real-shaped agency data (6 rows, 3 types, multiple created_by provenance values, generations 0-3, mixed parent_ids forms incl. empty array). (5) Byte-equal verified independently: md5 3447b88d0b76124f9177c89698f6fe91 matches between tests/fixtures/agency-starter-sample.csv and 'wg agency export --format agency-csv -' output. cargo test --test integration_agency_csv_roundtrip passes (2/2). Smoke scenario tests/smoke/scenarios/agency_csv_roundtrip.sh PASS. (6) File scope respected: commit a723bed47 touches only cli.rs, main.rs, commands/agency_{import,push,init}.rs, tests/*. ZERO changes to src/agency/hash.rs or src/agency/types.rs. CONCERN (minor, non-blocking, out of scope for this task): the deliverable bullet 'wrote primitives that show up in wg agency stats' is only partially satisfied — wg agency stats reports TradeoffConfigs:2 (matches) but does NOT list RoleComponent or DesiredOutcome counts (display limitation in stats.rs, preexisting). The primitives ARE written to .wg/agency/primitives/{components,outcomes,tradeoffs}/<hash>.yaml (verified via ls + integration test test_agency_csv_import_reads_lineage_columns). Suggest follow-up: extend wg agency stats to display component/outcome counts.
2026-05-04T19:20:47.677511682+00:00 Validated: read agency_import.rs + agency_push.rs diffs; independently round-tripped fixture (md5 byte-equal); domain comma-separated and parent_ids JSON conventions confirmed; verdict posted.
2026-05-04T19:21:21.175853707+00:00 Task pending eval (agent reported done; awaiting `.evaluate-*` to score)
2026-05-04T19:22:15.904336976+00:00 PendingEval → Done (evaluator passed; downstream unblocks)