Metadata
| Status | done |
|---|---|
| Assigned | agent-2457 |
| Agent identity | 5f5f9e1ac73378e8fc64f7603d5ad052f5e6e30285efe8415814579e618bd37d |
| Created | 2026-05-04T21:08:48.842478111+00:00 |
| Started | 2026-05-04T21:12:42.088412130+00:00 |
| Completed | 2026-05-04T21:42:24.736025266+00:00 |
| Tags | eval-scheduled |
| Eval score | 0.72 |
| └ blocking impact | 0.85 |
| └ completeness | 0.78 |
| └ coordination overhead | 0.86 |
| └ correctness | 0.72 |
| └ downstream usability | 0.80 |
| └ efficiency | 0.76 |
| └ intent fidelity | 0.56 |
| └ style adherence | 0.85 |
Description
Description
End-to-end smoke synth-agency-end-to-end found that wg agency import collapses rows the upstream starter.csv treats as distinct, producing semantic drift:
- 18 collapsed rows: upstream contains paired entries with the same (type, name) but different 'scope' (e.g. 'task' and 'meta:assigner'). wg's import keeps only one. Examples: forward-compatible-deferral-spec, ask-purpose-and-failure-before-fixing.
- 1 row truly lost: upstream's role_component identify-write-up-audience-and-adapt has identical description text to wg's seeded adapt-research-synthesis-for-non-domain-audience; on import, the upstream row is silently merged into the locally-seeded one (different name, different domain, different quality).
Decide and document the dedup rule. Options: (A) keep one row per (type, name, scope) tuple — preserves upstream's per-scope variants (B) keep one row per (type, name) and merge scopes — current behavior, document explicitly (C) keep one row per content_hash and emit warning when names collide
After deciding, either change behavior to match the chosen rule or add a 'wg agency import --strict' mode that errors on collisions.
Validation
- Decision documented in CLAUDE.md or docs/agency.md
- Behavior matches decision and includes a test exercising both scope-variant rows and same-description name collision
- cargo build + cargo test pass
Depends on
Required by
Log
- 2026-05-04T21:12:42.088416609+00:00 Spawned by coordinator --executor claude --model opus
- 2026-05-04T21:13:01.080330360+00:00 Starting investigation of agency import dedup rules. Will examine current dedup logic, decide on rule, and implement.
- 2026-05-04T21:38:56.587127289+00:00 Implemented Option C: dedup keeps first row per content_hash (sha256(description)); collisions warn+skip by default, --strict errors. Documented in docs/manual/03-agency.md 'Import Dedup Rule'. Tests: per-scope variant + same-description name collision. Smoke: agency_import_dedup_collision.sh.
- 2026-05-04T21:41:30.852479248+00:00 Committed: c8b57c3dc — pushed to remote
- 2026-05-04T21:42:01.344824878+00:00 Validated: cargo build OK; cargo test --bin wg agency_import = 30/30 pass; cargo test agency integration = 237/237 pass; live smoke confirms warn+strict behavior; smoke scenario agency_import_dedup_collision PASS.
- 2026-05-04T21:42:24.736036447+00:00 Task pending eval (agent reported done; awaiting `.evaluate-*` to score)
- 2026-05-04T21:44:26.859497458+00:00 PendingEval → Done (evaluator passed; downstream unblocks)