← graph

.verify-synchronization-pass-update

Verify (FLIP 0.45): Synchronization pass: update documents with founder decisions and discussion outcomes

Metadata

Statusabandoned
Assignedagent-48
Agent identity3184716484e6f0ea08bb13539daf07686ee79d440505f1fdf2de0357707034c3
Modelclaude-opus-4-6
Created2026-04-01T16:00:17.386136083+00:00
Started2026-04-01T16:00:22.323953167+00:00
Tagsverification, agency, eval-scheduled
Tokens0 in / 0 out
Eval score0.45
└ hallucination rate0.10
└ requirement coverage0.25
└ semantic match0.60
└ specificity match0.20

Description

FLIP Verification & Repair

FLIP score 0.45 is below threshold 0.70 — independently verify and, if needed, fix this task's work.

Your Authority

You are a senior engineer reviewing a junior's PR. You have full authority to:

  • Edit source files, run builds, run tests, and commit fixes
  • Correct mistakes, resolve test failures, and improve the implementation
  • Only reject (fail) the source task if the approach is fundamentally wrong

Fix first, fail last. If the work is close but has issues, repair it yourself.

Original Task

ID: synchronization-pass-update Title: Synchronization pass: update documents with founder decisions and discussion outcomes Description:

Objective

Perform a comprehensive synchronization pass across all Poietic, Inc. corporate documents, incorporating the decisions and discussion outcomes from the formation process so far.

Context

  • Poietic, Inc. is an EXISTING Delaware corporation (Stripe Atlas) converting to PBC
  • Founder: Erik Garrison (sole incorporator, initial director, initial officer)
  • Public benefit: "To develop open tools and frameworks that make human and machine collaboration legible and responsive to its participants"
  • Key decisions made during discussion:
    1. Vaughn's equity is DEFERRED — do NOT include Vaughn's equity grant in the current filing package. He will receive equity later via the individual/ITIN route, not the entity route.
    2. Erik's founder equity: needs to be included in the current package (4M Class A shares at $0.00001/share, 4-year vesting, 1-year cliff — confirm these defaults from the existing documents)
    3. This is a PBC CONVERSION, not a fresh formation — the Certificate of Incorporation already exists. We're filing a Certificate of Amendment.

Inputs

  • docs/decisions-needed.md — the 5 founder decisions form (READ THIS FIRST)
  • docs/compliance-review.md — the compliance review with issues and recommendations
  • docs/gap-analysis.md — consolidated gaps
  • All documents in corporate/amendments/pbc-conversion/ (or docs/pbc/ if reorg hasn't happened yet — check both locations)
  • All documents in corporate/ tree generally
  • The equity research docs

Tasks

1. Update the Decisions Form

Update decisions-needed.md (wherever it currently lives) to reflect:

  • Which decisions have been made (mark them resolved)
  • Which are still open
  • Add any new decisions surfaced by the compliance review
  • Specifically note: Vaughn equity = deferred, not part of this filing

2. Synchronize All .docx Documents

For each PBC amendment .docx file:

  • Apply any auto-fillable information from the compliance review recommendations
  • Ensure all docu

Artifacts:

  • corporate/research/decisions/decisions-needed.md

FLIP Evaluation Results

Dimension scores:

  • hallucination_rate: 0.10
  • requirement_coverage: 0.25
  • semantic_match: 0.60
  • specificity_match: 0.20

Evaluator reasoning: The inferred task correctly identifies the domain (corporate formation decisions, equity allocation, conversion context) but captures only a small fraction of the actual requirements. The actual task is a comprehensive four-part synchronization effort: (1) update decisions form, (2) synchronize all .docx files with consistency checks and Vaughn-equity deference, (3) create a detailed filing checklist, and (4) distinguish document types and filing destinations. The inferred version focuses narrowly on reviewing state and updating decisions-needed.md, then delegating remaining work as follow-up tasks. It misses nearly all specifics: the Vaughn-equity deferral policy, the .docx synchronization requirement, the FILING-CHECKLIST.md deliverable, the [FOUNDER INPUT NEEDED] tagging scheme, and the validation criteria. The framing also diverges: actual is action-oriented (perform sync), inferred is review-and-delegate-oriented.

FLIP metadata: {"comparison_model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","inference_model":"claude-sonnet-4-20250514","inferred_prompt":"Review the current state of corporate formation decisions and documentation. Check the repository structure for any resolved decisions regarding entity formation, equity allocation, and corporate structure. Update the decisions-needed.md document to reflect which decisions have been made (including founder equity, entity type/name, and conversion vs. fresh formation). Create appropriate follow-up tasks for any remaining document synchronization work needed to complete the corporate formation process."}

Verification Steps

Independently check whether the work was actually completed. Do NOT trust the original agent's claims.

  1. Check git log --oneline -10 for recent commits related to this task
  2. Check git diff to see if meaningful changes were made
  3. Run cargo build && cargo test to verify nothing is broken
  4. Verify any artifacts mentioned in the task description exist

Repair & Verdict

  • If everything looks good: log verification passed and mark this task done.
  • If problems found: fix them directly — edit code, resolve test failures, correct logic errors, then run the verification again. Commit your fixes with a descriptive message. Once fixed, mark this task done.
  • Only as a last resort, if the approach is fundamentally wrong and cannot be salvaged: run wg fail 'synchronization-pass-update' --reason "FLIP verification failed: <reason>" then mark this task done.

Remember: your job is to make the work pass, not to find reasons to reject it.

Depends on

Required by

Log